THE WANT LIST--'81 Our Critics' Annual Summary
Despite performances which I like less than P. S. does (see Fanfare IV:5), I strongly recommend the Wergo set of Karl Amadeus Hartmann's eight symphonies and Gesangsszene. These eloquent, powerful, at times shattering works reveal Hartmann as a major figure in the history of the symphony. This set fills a hole in the recorded repertory which had been staring at us for far too long. Another hole which has at last been given some attention was the nonexistence on records of any music by Kaikhosru Sorabji, who has written so much of such importance and difficulty that we will hardly be able to talk about an adequate recorded representation of him in this century. Michael Habermann's performance of some relatively early works is spellbinding.
As it is fashionable these days to take swipes at difficult music, Elliott Carter has gotten his share of them, mostly, I suspect from people without the desire or perhaps the ability to penetrate his necessarily complex style. Actually, the two newish pieces recorded on CBS (Symphony of Three Orchestras and A Mirror on Which to Dwell) are less abstruse than some earlier ones and form a fine introduction to his recent work.
Finally. I urge you to hear Ben Johnston's fourth quartet and Easley Blackwood's 12 etudes. These gentlemen often find themselves on opposite sides of discussions about pitch relations in microtonal music, but they are both fine composers whose above-mentioned works are ear-opening in ways that nothing else is. If you think microtonal music sounds awful or is only for Asian Indians, mathematicians, or kooks, then these records ought to change your mind. Given widespread dissemination of microtonal performing instruments (e.g., the Motorola Scalatron), music like this could change the courses of music history radically.
HARTMANN: The Eight Symphonies. Gesangszene. Various conductors/Bavarian
Radio Symphony Orchestra (WERGO 6OO86, five discs)
Copyright ©1981 by Paul Rapoport, all rights reserved.
Reprinted by permission